Areds2 Eye Vitamins: Comparing Macutec and Mdeyes

Areds2 Eye Vitamins: Comparing Macutec and Mdeyes

AREDS2 eye vitamins are a daily supplement designed to support macular health. This formulation is derived from two significant studies conducted in the United States and is available in Australia under various brand names, including Macutec and MDEyes.

They are not suitable for everyone. Below, we discuss who can benefit from them, their ingredients, and a comparison between Macutec and MDEyes.

Smiling older woman carrying a basket of vegetables outdoors

Understanding AREDS2 Eye Vitamins

AREDS stands for the Age-Related Eye Disease Study, initiated by the US National Eye Institute. The AREDS2 study served as a follow-up, resulting in an updated formula of vitamins and minerals that has been extensively tested.

The AREDS2 formulation includes the following essential nutrients:

  • Vitamin C
  • Vitamin E
  • Lutein
  • Zeaxanthin
  • Zinc
  • Copper

The original AREDS formula included beta-carotene, which has been replaced by lutein and zeaxanthin in the AREDS2 version.

Key Findings from the AREDS Studies

The National Eye Institute provides the following insights:

  • Use of AREDS or AREDS2 supplements can lower the risk of advancing from intermediate to advanced age-related macular degeneration (AMD) by approximately 25 per cent.
  • These supplements do not prevent the onset of AMD.
  • They do not influence the development of cataracts.
  • Omega-3 supplements have no impact on either AMD or cataracts.
  • Individuals who currently smoke or have a history of smoking should opt for the AREDS2 formula, avoiding the older version containing beta-carotene, which may elevate lung cancer risk.

Who Should Consider AREDS2 Eye Vitamins?

According to the Macular Disease Foundation Australia, you may find AREDS2 supplements beneficial if you have:

  • Intermediate stage AMD in one or both eyes, or
  • Late stage AMD (either dry or wet) in a single eye.

The Foundation advises against their use if you do not have AMD, if you exhibit only early signs of AMD, or if you have late stage AMD in both eyes. AREDS2 supplements are not a cure and cannot reverse any existing damage.

Start with an eye examination. Your optometrist can determine if you have AMD, identify its stage, and assess whether AREDS2 vitamins are appropriate for your condition.

Essential Questions for Your Optometrist Regarding AREDS2 Vitamins

In Australia, you do not require a referral to consult an optometrist, and healthdirect indicates that Medicare covers eye tests performed by optometrists for permanent residents. Bring these questions to your appointment:

  • Do I have AMD, and is it present in one eye or both?
  • What is the stage of AMD: early, intermediate, or late?
  • Would an AREDS2 supplement be suitable for me, considering my current medications?
  • How frequently should I schedule follow-up appointments?
  • Should I be using an Amsler grid at home to monitor changes in my vision?

When to Seek Immediate Eye Care

AMD typically progresses without pain, so you may not notice changes in your vision. Healthdirect advises contacting an eye specialist promptly if you observe any of the following symptoms:

  • Blurry vision
  • Straight lines appearing wavy or distorted
  • Difficulty recognising faces
  • Increased need for light to read or see clearly
  • Decreased night vision

The main risk factors for AMD include increasing age, smoking, and family history. Approximately 1 in 7 individuals over 50 exhibit signs of AMD.

Comparing Macutec and MDEyes: Ingredient Analysis

Both brands offer identical nutrients in the same quantities in each daily capsule:

  • Vitamin C (ascorbic acid): 500 mg
  • Vitamin E (dl-alpha tocopheryl acetate): 400 mg, equivalent to 400 IU
  • Lutein: 10 mg
  • Zeaxanthin: 2 mg
  • Zinc (from zinc oxide): 25 mg
  • Copper: 2 mg

Both products are free from beta-carotene, which is crucial for smokers or former smokers. While the original AREDS2 formula contained 80 mg of zinc, both Macutec and MDEyes provide 25 mg. The AREDS2 trial also evaluated a lower zinc dosage and found it did not significantly affect the progression to advanced AMD.

The primary differences lie in their packaging and pricing per daily dose.

Macutec Once Daily

Take one capsule daily with your evening meal. A bottle of 120 capsules is priced at $75, lasting approximately four months, which averages out to about 63 cents per day. See Macutec Once Daily.

MDEyes

Take one capsule daily with food. Each package contains 28 blister-sealed capsules, equating to four weeks of supply. See MDEyes.

  • 1 packet (28 capsules): $23.95, around 86 cents per day
  • 3 packets (84 capsules): $71.85, around 86 cents per day
  • 6 packets (168 capsules): $136.50, about 81 cents per day
  • 12 packets (336 capsules): $258.65, approximately 77 cents per day, providing nearly a year’s supply

Duration of Taking AREDS2 Eye Vitamins

Both brands recommend one capsule daily, with no initial loading dose required. MDEyes suggests ongoing use. Since it is a daily supplement, larger packs offer better value per day.

  • One bottle of Macutec lasts about four months.
  • Twelve packets of MDEyes provide nearly a year’s supply.

Set a reminder to reorder a couple of weeks before your supply runs out to prevent any gaps in your regimen.

Lutein and Zeaxanthin: Are They Equivalent to AREDS2?

No, lutein and zeaxanthin are just two of the six nutrients in the AREDS2 formulation. While lutein is available as a standalone supplement, it does not equate to the AREDS2 formula. If your optometrist recommends AREDS2, verify the label for all six nutrients and their respective amounts.

AREDS2 Eye Vitamins vs. Dry Eye Supplements: Understanding the Difference

It is easy to confuse these two, but they serve distinct purposes. AREDS2 vitamins focus on macular health and do not contain omega-3. In contrast, the dry eye supplements available contain omega-3 fish oil. The National Eye Institute has determined that omega-3 does not influence AMD, and the Macular Disease Foundation Australia suggests there is insufficient evidence supporting omega-3 supplements for AMD compared to consuming fish.

If dry eyes are your concern, refer to our guide on dry eye supplements available in Australia.

Consult Your Doctor Before Starting AREDS2 Eye Vitamins

  • Individuals taking other medications or supplements. The Macular Disease Foundation Australia notes that some vitamins may interact with specific medications.
  • Women who are pregnant or breastfeeding. MDEyes is not recommended during these periods.
  • Individuals under 18, specifically for MDEyes.
  • Those already consuming vitamin C, vitamin E, or zinc in other products. Be sure to calculate the total amounts.

If you experience any new or unusual symptoms after initiating a supplement, consult your eye health professional promptly.

Common Questions About AREDS2 Eye Vitamins

Do AREDS2 Vitamins Prevent Macular Degeneration?

No, both the National Eye Institute and the Macular Disease Foundation Australia confirm that these vitamins do not prevent the onset of AMD.

Can Smokers Take AREDS2 Vitamins?

Current and former smokers should opt for AREDS2, avoiding the previous formula that contains beta-carotene. Both Macutec and MDEyes are free from beta-carotene.

Are Macutec and MDEyes the Same Product?

Both brands contain the same six nutrients in identical amounts. Their differences lie in packaging, daily cost, and dosing instructions (Macutec recommends taking it with your evening meal).

Can I Combine AREDS2 Vitamins with a Dry Eye Supplement?

Consult your pharmacist or optometrist before doing so. Both Macutec and MDEyes provide 400 mg of vitamin E, and some dry eye supplements, like DRYeye Forte, may also include vitamin E, so it is important to total your intake.

Purchase AREDS2 Eye Vitamins Online in Australia

We deliver across Australia. Since these vitamins are taken daily, larger packs offer the best value per day.

  • Macutec Once Daily, 120 capsules, $75, approximately four months
  • MDEyes, 12 packets (336 capsules), $258.65, nearly a year
  • MDEyes, 6 packets (168 capsules), $136.50, around six months

Explore our full range of eye supplements.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Please read the label and use only as directed. If symptoms persist, consult your healthcare professional.

Original Article First Published At: AREDS2 Eye Vitamins: Macutec vs MDEyes and Who They Suit

WriteBuff, is proudly based in Australia, is a dedicated content syndication platform serving trade publications and niche professional audiences across sectors like construction, manufacturing, automotive, and more. Their mission is to amplify valuable trade content by distributing it to relevant, high-authority partner platforms, enhancing visibility and engagement for both authors and publishers.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *